Skip to content

Indiana Public Pensions in Divorce: INPRS Cannot Honor a QDRO

Why an Indiana QDRO cannot divide a PERF, TRF or 1977 Fund pension: the INPRS refusal, the exemption statutes, what INPRS says a divorce decree should do instead, and survivor changes after divorce.

Find out where you stand in Indiana

DocDraft provides document preparation, not legal advice.

Introduction

Payments to an ex-spouse from an Indiana PERF, TRF or 1977 Fund pension come from the member, not from INPRS, because the Indiana Public Retirement System says it cannot honor any QDRO, the court order that elsewhere directs a plan to pay a former spouse directly. Each INPRS member handbook says Indiana law prevents assigning these benefits, so INPRS cannot honor any divorce decree requiring it to pay anyone other than the member or the member's designated beneficiary. The handbooks say decrees should instead order the member, or the legal beneficiary, to make payments to an ex-spouse. The rule covers the defined contribution account, formerly the annuity savings account, as well as the monthly pension, and the DC-only My Choice plans say the same. Indiana Code Section 5-10.3-8-9 (PERF) and Section 5-10.4-5-14 (TRF) exempt benefits from garnishment, attachment and other legal process; confirm the current text of those sections with INPRS. A private employer 401(k) or pension follows federal rules, covered on our national QDRO page, and other plans have their own rules.

Key Things to Know

  1. 1

    An Indiana divorce decree that touches a PERF, TRF or 1977 Fund pension works as an order against the member personally, not against the fund. INPRS handbooks say that, to be consistent with the laws governing each fund and to satisfy Indiana's domestic relations laws, decrees should order the member, or the legal beneficiary, to make payments to an ex-spouse rather than ordering INPRS to make such payments.

  2. 2

    The refusal is stated plainly and repeated plan by plan. The PERF Hybrid, TRF Hybrid, PERF My Choice, TRF My Choice and 1977 Fund handbooks each say INPRS cannot honor any QDRO, and each calls its plan a governmental plan exempt from the QDRO requirements. They also say INPRS cannot honor any divorce decree requiring it to pay anyone other than the member or the member's designated beneficiary.

  3. 3

    The defined contribution side is not an exception. A PERF Hybrid or TRF Hybrid benefit has a monthly pension and a DC account that the handbooks say was formerly known as the annuity savings account, funded by a 3 percent mandatory contribution. The My Choice plans are DC-only, and their handbooks still say INPRS cannot honor any QDRO.

  4. 4

    Indiana Code Section 5-10.3-8-9(a) makes all PERF benefits, refunds of contributions and money in the fund exempt from levy, sale, garnishment, attachment, or other legal process. Section 5-10.3-8-10 says a member or beneficiary may not assign any payment except insurance premiums and dues to a qualifying retiree association. For TRF, Section 5-10.4-5-14.5 says a member's transfer of a benefit payment is void, with the same two exceptions.

  5. 5

    One narrow opening appears in the handbooks: if you purchase an annuity or roll over funds to another plan outside of INPRS, the handbooks say the QDRO bar may not apply, and the PERF My Choice handbook adds that you should consult the administrator for that plan. Nothing in the handbooks lets INPRS itself split an account.

  6. 6

    Indiana courts still divide the value. In Smith v. Smith (2022), the Court of Appeals of Indiana said a trial court is prohibited from dividing an INPRS pension by QDRO or ordering the member to assign payments, but must still divide the marital estate under Indiana Code Section 31-15-7-4 and may order an equalization payment or payments. The opinion describes immediate offset, deferred distribution paid directly by the member, and installment combinations.

  7. 7

    Survivor protection has to be handled in the decree. Smith held the trial court erred by awarding neither survivor's benefits nor protection of the former spouse's portion through another means, such as life insurance. After retirement, the PERF Hybrid handbook says removing a living spouse as survivor needs a divorce decree or the spouse's consent, and a fee may be assessed after the first change.

Key decisions before you file

Before you file a Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) in Indiana, a few decisions shape the document: which option to choose and what each one means. The Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) guide walks through them.

Open the Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) guide

Customize your Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO) Template with DocDraft

Indiana Requirements for Qualified Domestic Relations Order (QDRO)

  • The INPRS Fund and Plan the Member Belongs To

    Identify whether the benefit is in PERF Hybrid, PERF My Choice, TRF Hybrid, TRF My Choice or the 1977 Police Officers' and Firefighters' Fund. Each INPRS handbook carries the same refusal: INPRS cannot honor any QDRO. Hybrid plans have both a monthly pension and a DC account, formerly the annuity savings account.

  • A Decree That Orders the Member, Not INPRS, to Pay

    INPRS says decrees should order the member, or the legal beneficiary, to make payments to an ex-spouse rather than ordering INPRS to make such payments, and that it cannot honor any decree requiring it to pay anyone other than the member or designated beneficiary. A paragraph directing INPRS to pay is one INPRS says it cannot honor.

  • The Exemption Statutes for PERF and TRF Benefits

    Indiana Code Section 5-10.3-8-9(a) exempts PERF benefits, refunds and fund money from levy, sale, garnishment, attachment, or other legal process, and Section 5-10.3-8-10 bars assignment except insurance premiums and qualifying association dues. Section 5-10.4-5-14 and Section 5-10.4-5-14.5 do the same for TRF. Confirm the current text with INPRS.

  • The Marital Share Valued for Offset or Deferred Payment

    In Smith v. Smith (2022), the Court of Appeals of Indiana said the trial court must still divide the marital estate under Indiana Code Section 31-15-7-4 and may order an equalization payment or payments. Record the service during the marriage, the DC balance and a pension estimate so the decree can set an offset, a deferred share paid by the member, or installments.

  • Payment Terms Binding the Member

    Because INPRS pays only the member or designated beneficiary, the decree has to spell out what the member pays the ex-spouse, when payments start, how they are made and by when each month. The Court of Appeals described deferred distribution where payment is ordered to come directly from the owning spouse.

  • Protection for the Ex-Spouse if the Member Dies

    Smith v. Smith held the trial court erred by failing to award either survivor's benefits or protection of the former spouse's portion of the pension through another means, such as life insurance. The decree should say which protection applies, since INPRS will not pay the former spouse under the decree.

  • Survivor and Beneficiary Changes Filed With INPRS

    The PERF Hybrid handbook says a retired member may change the survivor or benefit form on INPRS forms, not online. If a living spouse is removed, a divorce decree must be submitted, or the spouse must provide consent, and a fee may be assessed after the first change. DC account beneficiaries are designated through the member's online account.

  • Money Moved Outside INPRS

    The PERF Hybrid, PERF My Choice and 1977 Fund handbooks say that if the member purchases an annuity or moves funds to another plan outside INPRS, the QDRO bar may not apply, and the PERF My Choice handbook says to consult that plan's administrator. That plan, not INPRS, decides whether it will act on an order.

Frequently Asked Questions

Questions are loading.